Ethics & Dilemmas
Navigate real-world AI dilemmas with no easy answers. Explore different perspectives, examine your assumptions, and build a personal ethical framework for AI use.
There's often shame associated with using AI, a feeling that it's somehow "cheating" or undermines authentic work. But AI is a tool, and like any tool, the ethics lie in how we use it, not whether we use it at all.
This experience is about developing your judgement for the many situations where the "right" answer isn't obvious.
This experience has 6 steps. Work through each one at your own pace. You can revisit any completed step by clicking it in the progress bar above.
Work through these scenarios. There are no "right" answers. The goal is to examine your reasoning and consider perspectives you might have missed.
A student sends you an email asking for an extension. The writing is polished and uses phrases you recognise as typical AI output. The student has always been a strong communicator, but this email feels... different.
A colleague asks you to review a grant application they've drafted. It's well-written but seems generic. They mention they used "some AI assistance" but don't specify how much. The grant is important for the school.
A student with a documented learning disability has submitted work significantly better than their usual standard. You suspect AI involvement. The student hasn't disclosed AI use, but they have legitimate reasons to struggle with writing tasks.
Two more scenarios to consider. Remember, the goal is to examine your reasoning, not to find the "right" answer.
You're writing a paper and use AI to help structure your literature review. The AI suggests sources and synthesizes themes. You verify the sources exist and are relevant. You're not sure how much to acknowledge this assistance.
In a school meeting, a colleague advocates for banning all AI use in assessments. Another says that's unrealistic and disadvantages students. The Head of School asks for your view.
Would I be comfortable if my AI use were fully visible? Am I being honest about the level of AI involvement?
Can I explain and defend this work without AI? Do I actually understand the content I'm presenting?
Does this use of AI serve the underlying goal? Am I using AI to enhance my work or to avoid doing it?
Imagine your AI use was displayed on a billboard outside your building. Would you be comfortable with colleagues, students, and leadership seeing exactly how you used AI? If yes, you're in good ethical territory. If you feel the need to hide or minimize, that's worth examining.
Most AI ethics are contextual. What's appropriate depends on purpose, audience, and expectations
Transparency is usually the right default. When in doubt, disclose
Understanding matters more than process. Can you explain and defend your work?
Norms are evolving. Stay engaged in conversations about best practices
Great work! Your progress has been recorded.
Checking your badge progress...
Once you've worked through the scenarios above, click below to record your progress.